The controversy surrounding Roy Williams being ranked above Mike Krzyzewski, also known as Coach K, on The Athletic’s Top 25 Coaches list has sparked heated debates among college basketball fans. Here are the key points to consider:
*The Rankings*
– Roy Williams is ranked No. 2 on the list, with Bill Self taking the top spot and Coach K at No. 3.
– The ranking is based on the coaches’ performance since 2000, with Williams edging out Coach K due to his two more Final Four appearances and double the conference regular-season titles during this period ¹.
*The Case for Roy Williams*
– Williams’ impressive resume includes:
– *3 National Championships*: 2005, 2009, and 2017
– *7 Final Four appearances*: Tied for the most in the 2000s
– *11 Conference Regular-Season Titles*: Double Coach K’s titles in the same period
– *574 Wins Since 2000*: Averaging 27.3 wins per season
– Williams’ ability to build and sustain a dynasty at Kansas and North Carolina, with a strong emphasis on team-first mentality and player development ¹ ².
*The Case for Coach K*
– Coach K’s achievements include:
– *5 National Championships*: 3 since 2000
– *13 ACC Tournament Titles*
– *12 No. 1 Seeds in the NCAA Tournament*
– *Over 700 Wins*: A testament to his enduring legacy
– Coach K’s impact on the game extends beyond his wins, with a strong focus on discipline, excellence, and innovation ³.
*The Reaction*
– Duke fans are furious, arguing that Coach K’s resume speaks for itself and that he should be ranked higher.
– North Carolina fans, on the other hand, are celebrating the recognition of Williams’ greatness and defending his ranking ¹ ³.
Ultimately, the debate comes down to subjective interpretation and personal opinion. Both coaches are legends of the sport, and their contributions to college basketball are undeniable. The Athletic’s ranking may have sparked controversy, but it also highlights the complexity and nuance of evaluating coaching greatness.
