Breaking news: Carolina Panthers On SI Saints Players, Coaches Complain About Penalty vs. Panthers, But They’re Wrong

Saints Players, Coaches Complain About Penalty vs. Panthers, But They’re Wrong

By Tim Weaver | Carolina Panthers On SI | November 16, 2026

The Carolina Panthers escaped New Orleans with a 20-17 walk-off win on Sunday, but the postgame conversation wasn’t about Ryan Fitzgerald’s clutch kick or Chuba Hubbard’s career day. Instead, it was about a flag.

Saints cornerback Kool-Aid McKinstry was flagged for a 30-yard defensive pass interference penalty with 21 seconds left, setting up Carolina at the New Orleans 36-yard line and paving the way for Fitzgerald’s game-winner. McKinstry called it “horrible, horrible” and said teammates rushed to tell him it was a “bad call”. Cam Jordan took to social media, quote-tweeting the video with “What is OPI,” suggesting offensive pass interference should have been called.

Here’s the problem: the Saints are wrong.

This was textbook defensive pass interference. McKinstry ran into Jalen Coker, prevented him from making a play on the ball, and never remotely turned his head to locate the pass. Complain about the rule itself, it often bails out underthrown balls, and Bryce Young’s pass was indeed underthrown, but this was as clear-cut as it gets under the current rulebook. The irony is staggering. Earlier in the game, Panthers cornerback Corey Thornton did literally the exact same thing to Chris Olave near the goal line. He crashed into the receiver before the ball arrived and never looked back. It was correctly flagged, and nobody in New Orleans was outraged about the rule then.

Even Saints head coach Kellen Moore, to his credit, acknowledged the broader picture. “We had plenty of opportunities in this game,” Moore said. “We didn’t get it done”. He admitted the Saints benefited from plenty of calls. That’s an understatement. The replacement officiating crew, thrust into duty due to the FAA shutdown, was dreadful, and the Panthers were on the wrong end of it for most of the afternoon. An incorrect horse-collar call set up a Saints score. A phantom facemask put New Orleans in field-goal range to tie the game with under a minute left. Carolina was flagged a franchise-record 17 times for 152 yards while the Saints drew just three flags for 46 yards. None of that excuses Carolina’s discipline problem. Seventeen penalties is unsustainable, and Dave Canales knows it. “When the margins get tighter, it makes it really hard to win that way,” he said. “We have to fix that”. But the call that decided the game was correct. The Saints can complain all they want, but the film doesn’t lie. If anything, the outrage should be directed at the crew that let a phantom facemask stand and waved off a Chuba Hubbard touchdown on a holding call that never happened. The rematch in Charlotte later this year just got a little more interesting.

Post Comment